Ranking the Troughton era

[Brian MK.II]

I can only see a thread for ranking the surviving serials so here's one for the whole era.

Classics
1: The Web of Fear
2: Evil of the Daleks
3: The Invasion
4: Enemy of the World
5: The War Games
6: Fury from the Deep
7: The Mind Robber
8: Power of the Daleks
9: Tomb of the Cybermen
10: The Moonbase

Great to Good
11: The Abominable Snowmen
12: The Krotons
13: The Faceless Ones
14: The Seeds of Death
15: The Wheel in Space
16: The Underwater Menace

Average
17: The Ice Warriors
18: The Dominators
19: The Highlanders

Crap
20: The Space Pirates ( I love the production values, model work and Dudley Simpson's score but the story itself is non-existent figuratively as it is literally.)
21: The Macra Terror

[Ludders II]

TOP FAVES

1. The Moonbase
2. Evil of the Daleks
3. Tomb of the Cybermen
4. The Invasion
5. Power of the Daleks

VERY GOOD/ENJOYABLE

6. Wheel in Space
7. Seeds of Death
8. The Abominable Snowmen
9. The War Games
10. Web of Fear

GOOD

11. Fury from the Deep
12. The Mind Robber
13. The Faceless Ones

NOT BAD/AVERAGE

14. The Krotons
15. The Ice Warriors
16. The Dominators
17. The Macra Terror
18. The Underwater Menace

BORING

19. The Space Pirates
20. Enemy of the World

NEVER AGAIN

21. The Highlanders

[burrunjor]

Classics

Invasion.
The Mind Robber
Seeds of Death
The Power of the Daleks
The Evil of the Daleks
The Tomb of the Cybermen
The War Games
The Web of Fear
The Abominable Snowman

Good

The Moonbase
Fury From The Deep
Enemy of the World
The Wheel in Space

Boring or average at best

The Dominators
The Krotons
The Ice Warriors
The Faceless Ones
The Macra Terror
The Highlanders
The Space Pirates

I think Troughton's first season to be honest apart from the two excellent Dalek adventures is a bit of a slog. 

[Cherry Pepsi Maxil]

God Tier:

The War Games
The Tomb of the Cybermen
The Invasion
The Power of the Daleks
The Moonbase
The Underwater Menace
The Web of Fear
The Evil of the Daleks

Very Good:

The Wheel in Space
The Enemy of the World
The Ice Warriors
Fury from the Deep
The Mind Robber
The Faceless Ones
The Highlanders
The Abominable Snowmen



Average:

The Krotons
The Dominators
The Space Pirates
The Macra Terror
The Seeds of Death


I don't think any of his serials are dreadful. Even Seeds, which I find slightly dull at times, is acceptable.

[rushy]

CLASSICS
1. The War Games
2. The Evil of the Daleks
3. The Enemy of the World
4. The Web of Fear
5. The Power of the Daleks
6. The Abominable Snowmen
7. The Mind Robber
8. The Seeds of Death

GOOD
9. The Wheel in Space
10. The Moonbase
11. Fury from the Deep
12. The Tomb of the Cybermen
13. The Invasion
14. The Faceless Ones

MEH
15. The Ice Warriors
16. The Underwater Menace

RUBBISH
17. The Dominators
18. The Highlanders
19. The Macra Terror
20. The Space Pirates
21. The Krotons