What a joke colliders ranking Is

[Deleted]

Collider ranked best to worst regenerations Tom's into peters was dead last and Matt's into capaldi's was ranked number one what a joke 🤣🤣

[Deleted]

Here is the link to it
collider.com/doctor-who-all-regeneration-ranked/

[rushy]

lol at "John Hurt to CGI Eccleston" being at #4

[Deleted]

Lol yeah it's a pretty biased new who ranking I feel

[Deleted]

All the classic ones should be ranked higher

[iank]

lol Was it compiled by monkeys?

[Deleted]

Iank must be the third to fourth regeneration first to second fourth to sixth regenerations all masterpieces and they are ranked quite low they must have Brains less then the size of a grape 😂😂😂😂

[Deleted]

Davison to Baker is the best, clearly.

[Deleted]

There's no getting around the Colin to McCoy one, it was a sad result of behind the scenes crap and I dont blame Colin for telling them were to stick it.

Tom's one baffles me and you can tell these twats never actually watched that season in full. Season 18 is one, long count down to his death and Tom is still the longest severing Doctor of all. He WAS the Doctor for many and there real was the question of how the show could continue without him. 80s bashers say it never did... The Watcher represents the future. It is unknown, ethereal and scary, but it is there, promising the hope of tomorrow. As one dies, another is born. It a very important moment in the franchises history regardless of what we all think of Logopalis as an actual story. It's important for the Fourth Doctor given how long he was on screen.

This is not the first time I've seen people really miss the point. I had the bad luck of running into a podcast called Whobackwhen, and sorry for anyone who may be a member of it/or like it, but the complete lack of understanding of that, as well as aspects of other stories just blew my mind. To them the Watcher was equitable to the Timeless Child for some reason for beyond my understanding. But then deeper themes and nuwho never really did mesh did they?

Hartnell was the first and it was done because he was ill, had he not been it's likely he'd have been the one and only Doctor for many years and the show would have ended with him. Yes it's not the most exciting but very appropriate For the Actor and Character. For it was the first passing of the torch.

As for Pertwee, well it was again a sad product of circumstances due to Delgado's death. They made the best of it and he at least died the bravely, the way the Third Doctor should have done.

How Davison's is so low I'll never f*cking now. The cloest nuwho ever got was with Nines death, which sadly begins nuwho's trend of Doctor's unable to shut up befor they die. Tennent pisses and moans all the way to end, Smith's is ruined by regeneration lasers and Capaldi's was basically the beginning of the f*cking end for nuwho.

If there was any justice in the universe Jodie's end would be in shame and dishonour.

[Deleted]

It is such a joke though seriously I've looked at a few rankings and the classic regenerations always Rank lower apparently it's because oh new who had better effects I disagree at least classic who has more character to the regenerations no subtlety to these new ones all bombastic and they freaking stand up when they regenerate

[rushy]

#1. Eccleston to Tennant - I have very fond memories of this one, but it's legitimately a good way to go. It makes sense for Nine to go out standing on his feet, finally being happy with himself.

#2. McGann to Hurt - Though I'm not happy with McGann not being the War Doctor, I think he acts the hell out of his death scene. He's also one of the few actors to almost make Moffat's dialogue sound dignified, because he doesn't ham it up.

#3. Troughton to Pertwee - I love how dark and twisted it is, and that we never really see the first moments of Pertwee's Doctor. It's left open to the imagination.

#4. Tennant to Smith - As an ardent End of Time defender, I will stand by this being a powerful exit. I 100% get why he wouldn't want to regenerate, and emotionally it worked for me.

#5. Davison to Colin - I'm not a fan of the SFX used, but it's otherwise a very good exit. Love how the Master dominates the scene.

#6. Pertwee to Tom - Nicely understated. Much like the rest of Pertwee's era, they play it straight without any pretense.

#7. Hartnell to Troughton - There's no real emotion in it, but I kinda like that in its own way. The First Doctor was never very open, so it feels appropriate that he would just try and keep a stiff upper lip until the last. I also dig how surreal the moment is, what with the TARDIS coming to life and all. The first scenes with Troughton in Power of the Daleks are also amazing.

#8. Tom to Davison - I like parts of Logopolis, but the direction for Tom's death scene is terrible. The cutout Master, the way Adric, Nyssa and Tegan all react at different times, Tom not even looking like he's struggling, the shabby editing on the flashbacks... in concept, it's an awesome way for the Fourth Doctor to go. But I can't rank it higher, because they execute it so badly.

#9. McCoy to McGann - The smartest Doctor getting gunned down and gutted on the table is very amusing.

#10. Smith to Capaldi - I appreciate Smith's acting, but him turning young again felt forced, and his speech just felt coddling to me. "There will be a new Doctor and he's different but that's okay and I will be here in spirit so everything is fine..."

#11. Capaldi to Whittaker - Much the same as #10, except Peter had even less to work with. And his tangent about children knowing the Doctor's name was... well, bizarre.

#12. Hurt to Eccleston - I dislike this regeneration on multiple levels. One, because of the way they had to work around Eccleston's absence. Two, because the War Doctor hadn't displayed any signs of being near death. Three, because it would've been so much more interesting if the War Doctor survived to have more adventures and we never find out how and when he actually regenerated. This regeneration just feels like Moffat is doing it for the sake of it, because he is.

#13. Colin to McCoy - We all know this.

[cyberhat]

May 16, 2022 21:13:17 GMT @gusgorman83 said:

Davison to Baker is the best, clearly.

Clearly, I love how it has it's own sort of mini-plot within the regeneration. Apparently not worth shit though compared to a big yellow explosion repeated over and over again.