The Davison era vs the Colin Baker era

[Deleted]

Definitely Davison. To be fair, it's difficult to compare since Davison had eight more stories than Baker. However I do think  Davison's best stuff is better than Colin's best. Both are good though.

[iank]

I prefer Colin's. The 5th Doctor is my least fave classic Doctor, I'm not a fan of most of his companions and there is a humourless as well as plastic feel to a lot of the era (esp season 19) that I find a bit dreary these days.
Trial is awful but I like season 22 more than any Davison era and his Doctor appeals to me more too.

[rushy]

Davison brought something more unique to the part, and some of his stories (Castrovalva, Snakedance, Enlightenment) stand out more.

[Deleted]

I personally like Davison more as the Doctor. Some of you will remember that I loved Colin back when I first joined, but he just keeps going down in my list. I think Peter is a better actor and I don't think any of his performances were as bad as Colin's in Mindwarp.

[RobFilth]

Vs Season 22 - Baker wins
Vs Season 23 - Davison wins.